GasBuddy Blog

Message Forum - Read Message

Category: Talk back to us! > Topics	Add to favorite topics Post New Topic

Author	Topic: The reasonableness checker is unreasonable	Post a Reply Back to Topics

jrsva Champion Author Virginia Posts:9,852 Points:1,613,000 Joined:Jan 2006	Message Posted: Sep 9, 2011 10:06:36 PM Ignore jrsva Report Abuse GB’s reasonableness checker for prices seems a bit nutty right now. I got this message while posting a price for premium — “4.05 seems high. Did you mean 3.05?” Someone please tell me where I can get premium (or even regular) for $3.05 these days.

jrsva

Champion Author
Virginia

Posts:9,852
Points:1,613,000
Joined:Jan 2006

Message Posted: Sep 9, 2011 10:06:36 PM

Ignore jrsva Report Abuse

GB’s reasonableness checker for prices seems a bit nutty right now.
I got this message while posting a price for premium —
“4.05 seems high. Did you mean 3.05?”
Someone please tell me where I can get premium (or even regular) for $3.05 these days.

REPLIES (newest first)Ignore Short Messages

jrsva Champion Author Virginia Posts:9,852 Points:1,613,000 Joined:Jan 2006	Message Posted: Sep 14, 2011 10:02:45 PM Ignore jrsva Report Abuse Today I entered $3.93 for regular at a small country store (expected to be high) and the reasonableness checker had no complaints. That is 45¢ above the state average of $3.48. It landed near the top of the state-high list, the only station on that list outside of the northern Virginia high-price area.
gspecilk236 Veteran Author Harrisburg Posts:393 Points:103,935 Joined:Mar 2011	Message Posted: Sep 14, 2011 6:35:41 AM Ignore gspecilk236 Report Abuse Wow I did not even know there was a reasonableness checker. I haven't gotten a message so far.
jrsva Champion Author Virginia Posts:9,852 Points:1,613,000 Joined:Jan 2006	Message Posted: Sep 13, 2011 11:42:50 PM Ignore jrsva Report Abuse Looking at today’s GB Blog one sees that the hi/lo range can be close to $1.00 in some areas. Perhaps the algorithm should compare an entry to the average price for the same grade and the same state, showing a warning if the entry is not within ±50¢ of the average. That might put up a few false warnings but very few.
kwzh Champion Author San Jose Posts:20,649 Points:3,683,360 Joined:Jul 2001	Message Posted: Sep 12, 2011 2:18:57 AM Ignore kwzh Report Abuse 1.00 is way too large a spread -- I'd guess something like 0.40, or measure it in terms of standard deviations instead of absolutes.
drivefast99 Champion Author Greensboro Posts:2,317 Points:378,945 Joined:Jul 2011	Message Posted: Sep 11, 2011 8:48:19 PM Ignore drivefast99 Report Abuse I like kwzh's idea. What if the algorithm looked at the average price for each grade (including diesel) and +/- 1.00.
CampKohler Champion Author Sacramento Posts:9,463 Points:1,563,165 Joined:May 2007	Message Posted: Sep 11, 2011 5:15:10 PM Ignore CampKohler Report Abuse Does it even check for diesel? I seem to be able to put anything in there without it hiccupping.
jrsva Champion Author Virginia Posts:9,852 Points:1,613,000 Joined:Jan 2006	Message Posted: Sep 11, 2011 7:40:51 AM Ignore jrsva Report Abuse Virginia prices range from $3.30 to 3.89 for regular and $3.48 to 4.39 for premium, so $4.05 is well inside the range. I think kwzh has the right idea for the problem and the fix.
kwzh Champion Author San Jose Posts:20,649 Points:3,683,360 Joined:Jul 2001	Message Posted: Sep 10, 2011 11:02:48 PM Ignore kwzh Report Abuse Permanently solve the problem? Probably not. As prices climb and cause the previously unreasonable number to be reasonable, we'd find a flood of people who can't remember how they set that limit a few months ago... Anyway, I assume that the algorithm adapts to the current price range, rather than needing to be periodically reset by someone; I'd rather keep that, than be expected to update some hard limits every now and then. In fact, I'd probably just set extreme limits (1.00 - 10.00) just to avoid the annoying dialog box, and that would render it useless. Let's keep the algorithm, but fix it. Wild guess: the algorithm ignores fuel type when checking reasonableness. (Current VA prices seem to be about 3.50 for regular, so the 3.05 guess does seem more likely in that context.) Fix: determine appropriate limits for each fuel type separately.
CampKohler Champion Author Sacramento Posts:9,463 Points:1,563,165 Joined:May 2007	Message Posted: Sep 10, 2011 1:01:47 PM Ignore CampKohler Report Abuse Some time ago before the reasonableness checker was checking for reasonableness, I suggested that each member be allowed to set his own limits. That would take the storage of only two prices per member and would permanently solve the problem.
ziyulu Champion Author Oklahoma City Posts:8,499 Points:1,602,875 Joined:Aug 2007	Message Posted: Sep 10, 2011 9:21:48 AM Ignore ziyulu Report Abuse You can get regular gasoline for about $3 per gallon in Mexico.
NHLiveFree Champion Author New Hampshire Posts:11,095 Points:1,623,180 Joined:Jun 2008	Message Posted: Sep 9, 2011 10:45:11 PM Ignore NHLiveFree Report Abuse An unreasonable reasonableness checker sounds just right for GB and PD's Newsville.